Having just read the blog on the BBC website, felt the need to write down my opinion on the subject. Much of course will come from the two back to back victories England have just earnt themselves against the Euro and World Champions Spain, and a team we haven’t beat in 43 years Sweden.
Against Spain, England weren’t fantastic but what they were was resolute. They stood firm, defended magnificently as a team with Scott Parker being at the forefront of that effort and more than warranted his ovation 5 minutes from time and the MotM performance. Since he has come back into the squad Parker has shown what idiots previous England managers have been in previous years not to incorporate him into the team. I honestly think if he had been playing the last couple of years, which in fairness he should have been, he was only left out because he was playing excellently in a struggling West Ham team, that would have given the freedom Lampard and Gerrard required to both get forward and do what they have both done superbly for Chelsea and Liverpool respectively for most of the last decade without worrying who was going to stay and defend.
Another player who has been in manager’s good books somehow and gets picked is Gareth Barry. He isn’t international quality as he only has 1 foot and has no pace, and makes clumsy challenges. He came on against Spain and he was very lucky not to give away a penalty for a needless senseless challenge on Fabregas. He then gave away a freekick outside the box with an even clumsier challenge. Then to round off a fine hat-trick of poor play, who was the man who was supposed to be running back with Fabregas when he was alone in the box then shot wide, you guessed it, the tortoise paced Barry. If Scotty Parker had been his marker the ball would have been blocked, but Barry let Fabregas escape him. I’m sure these 3 gaping cracks will be papered over by the fact that England beat the highly favoured Spain.
Then there is the problem with Phil Jones. He is obviously a squad player who can play in a number of positions to good effect. However, the position he played against Spain isn’t one of them. 3 times he received the ball after good passing from Parker and Lampard facing the Spanish defence, with their midfielders behind him. 3 times he picked the wrong ball or dilly-dallied in possession. If it had been Gerrard/Lampard/Rooney who the ball fell to then, then England could have been disappointed not to have won 3 or even 4 to zip. The kid has the creativity of a breeze block. He is good running forward as he showed against Sweden sending the ball a foot wide of the post, but he just put his chest out, ears back and ran, not clever passing or insightful passing.
Granted, it was a good performance and deserves some celebration. However, Spain had lost 4 of their last 19 games. Those 4 were all friendlies. Maybe the defensive-counter attacking method is the way forward for England against the teams possessing better quality, which there are obviously a few, and with the pace of Walcott, directness of Young and Downing, there is no reason why that isn’t a tactic to employ.
Against Sweden it was a more attacking England, Zamora held the ball up well and linked with other players. Walcott terrorised and Downing deserved the MotM over Kyle Walker, but only just. Walker, Jones and Rodwell all performed well, but lets not heap the pressure on these kids like we have done before. And I’m sure we can all too painfully recall the results. The replies to the BBC sports blog about hope for 2012 for England of course meant there were a lot of “my squad would be” replies. Here’s my two penneths worth, providing they are all fit and well.
GK – Hart, Casrson, then pick another to fill the numbers.
DEF – Cole, Baines, Terry, Cahill, Jones, Lescott, Richards, Walker
MID – Parker, Wilshere, Rodwell, Lampard, Young, Walcott, Downing, Gerrard (Milner if not fit)
FOR – Rooney, Bent, Sturridge, Welbeck
Starting XI would be:-
Hart
Cole, Terry, Lescott, Richards,
Lampard, Parker, Gerrard,
Young, Bent, Walcott
Rodwell/Wilshere to come on for Lampard/Gerrard if necessary, Downing/Milner for Young/Walcott. Welbeck/Sturridge for Bent.
I don’t think we need to force a position for Jones. The kid is good, but not good enough to demand a position to himself. A lot of bloggers left the likes of Terry, Lampard, Gerrard, Lescott out completely and decided they’d take Smalling, Cleverly and a few other kids. That’s all well and good, and saying the old Golden generation need to pass onto the new Golden generation. No matter how good these kids are, they haven’t got the experience nor the cool head when it matters. There need to be some older heads around to keep the feet planted on the ground. 2012 is going to come too soon for Rodwell, Jones, Walker, Sturridge, Welbeck, Smalling, Wilshere. But remember these kids are young and when the trip to Rio and Sao Paolo comes around they’ll have another 100 Premier League games, maybe Champions League games under their belts and if they improve on their abilities already, then 2014 is certainly hopeful :)